Sunday, February 17, 2008

Flexcar in Southern California - A Post Mortem


The blogosphere has been ranting about the recent drastic reductions in Zipcar fleets in Los Angeles (or this or this colorful posting) and San Diego. News reports indicate Flexcar had only attracted about 800 members between the two cities. From a high of about 40 cars in Los Angeles and about the same number San Diego (I'm guessing here), all that's left are cars under contract at several universities in both cities.

It's never easy to take something away from loyal customers, but what's also gotten the blogosphere worked up is how poorly Zipcar seemed to handle the transition. Judging from the comments, members and prospective members were being told up by customer service until the day before the axe fell that everything was fine. On very short notice reservations were cancelled and memberships were cancelled. I'm surprised, too, because my impression is that Zipcar is generally pretty good in managing this kind of thing. If it's any consolation, Flexcar handled things similarly when it shut down its ill-fated expedition in San Jose several years earlier.

Zipcar made the decision that Flexcar had been unable or unwilling to make for several years. The financial bleeding of keeping these two cities alive was costing Flexcar dearly, yet the hope that the regional and local governments would really get behind carsharing was always just around the corner. And Flexcar's feast-or-famine approach and staff turnover, didn't help either.

A little history: Once upon a time American Honda Motors invested in Flexcar. Their hope was to meet the California Air Resources Board (CARB) Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) mandate in a clever way. None of the auto manufacturers wanted to sell a pure electric vehicle, which is what CARB had in mind (see Who Killed the Electric Car for details), so Honda got CARB to agree that a hybrid car in a carsharing fleet would count the same as a ZEV. (Toyota supported ZEVNet at UC Irvine. Ford had its Th!nk cars and Chrysler bought the GEM Neighborhood Electric Vehicle company and gave away NEVs claiming it should count the same as regular street legal car.) With that option, Honda needed a couple of hundred cars in Calfornia each year.

And it's worth remembering that at the time there were prospects for several million dollars of seed money from the California state legislature to encourage local governments to form partnerships with carsharing companies - so the stars certainly looked like they were lining up for carsharing.

San Francisco was the logical place for Flexcar to start but with City Carshare rates so low, Flexcar was afraid to tackle them head on so they came up their disastrous "pincher" strategy and launched Flexcar San Jose. Except for a diversion to Palo Alto, never got any further up the Penninsula. Given their size Los Angeles and San Diego were the other logical cities to start carsarhing. (Regrettably, Flexcar never got anything going in Sacramento, a city that was begging them to come, and one that they could have made a small but decent showing in.)

Los Angeles was the first city in southern California to be established. These were heady days for Flexcar when they seemed to think they could throw a lot of money anywhere and carsharing would stick. So, they started big - big in area, at least - with vehicles scattered (very thinly) all the way from Long Beach to Pasadena - more than 25 miles apart.

One of Flexcar's on-going problems always was follow-through - making promises it couldn't fulfill. LA was as good an example as anywhere. Another aspect of Flexcar in its heyday was that budgets alternated between feast or famine depending where they were in raising the next round of capital. So, things got launched with high hopes and then would suddenly get put on maintenance mode for 6-9 months until the next round of financing came through. But due to staff turnover the priorities in LA changed - from the initial we can blanket the area by starting with a few cars in a widespread area; to concentrating on downtown (but never quite shutting down the other areas) and finally concentrating on university fleets but never marketing to the surrounding neighborhoods. Now the universities are just about the only place where carsharing is left.

San Diego was the same story in a different setting. (Disclosure: one of my jobs for Flexcar was to set up the San Diego market, and I must admit I have a soft spot for San Diego - it's got real neighborhoods that you can actually walk in, a pretty vibrant and revitalizing downtown, light rail, heavy rail and pretty good bus service, as well as a forward looking regional planning organization, SANDAG.) But the same problems with funding and priorities prevented the orderly development in San Diego as well.

But the local governments in both Los Angeles and San Diego never seemed to "get" carsharing either, so a lot of their cooperation and support never seemed to get outside of the meeting rooms.

So is southern California the achilles heel of carsharing - proof that carsharing will never work there? I don't think so. Mostly I think it's a textbook example of how not to do things - in contrast to Zipcar's "eyes on the prize" style of doing business - concentrating on fewer cities and greater emphasis on direct contact with prospective customers. That said, neither city is your typical densely populated, parking congested, urban mecca, so some adjustments to the classic carsharing model are warranted.

The next operator to tackle carsharing in these cities needs to put a greater emphasis on partnerships with governments and major employers. And they probably need to adjust the fleet for the demographics of the area - a Honda Civic is not the one-size-fits-all vehicle for this marketplace. But this is just a start of the things to do differently next time - and should be a next time.

64 comments:

  1. Hey Dave, I saw you quoted in the Fast Company article, "Zipcar Makes the Leap." Great job.

    Adrian

    ReplyDelete
  2. i hope that such technology can go on being developed without hindrance from unfair business practices... take away people's ability to move and think and innovate freely and you weaken the country in general. it would seem that Big Oil is not very concerned about playing fairly in this way.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Aside from the complex physical connections that make up its infrastructure, the Internet is facilitated by bi- or multi-lateral commercial contracts (e.g., peering agreements), and by technical specifications or protocols that describe how to exchange data over the network. Indeed, the Internet is essentially defined by its interconnections and routing policies.

    As of December 30, 2007, 1.319 billion people use the Internet according to Internet World Stats. Writing in the Harvard International Review, philosopher N.J. Slabbert, a writer on policy issues for the Washington, D.C.–based Urban Land Institute, has asserted that the Internet is fast becoming a basic feature of global civilization, so that what has traditionally been called "civil society" is now becoming identical with information technology society as defined by Internet use. - web design company, web designer, web design india

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous2:11 PM

    Decent post but many assumptions. Flexcar actually had over 200 cars in Southern California collectively and over 10,000 members. Onstreet car sharing was being entertained by local government as a pilot program to help build sustainability. The spread-thin fleet would likely be the main cause of not being able to make ends meet in such a congested city but more city support would be needed to centralize the operation and create more dense neighborhoods of vehicles. Seems the city support might have been a couple years late. It would be nice however if government could take a proactive approach to supporting the system to create the type of sustainability they claim they're after. Private companies like Flexcar and Zipcar simply can't foot the bill alone in these monster-sized beuracratic governments in markets like LA where their help is a definite must.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Web Designer12:23 AM

    Thanks for this nice post.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous5:57 PM

    I hear there is a new carshare coming to los angeles, LAXCarshare.

    ReplyDelete
  7. i know Los angles is the state of innovation but i agree that you really put a good effort in it!
    i am a Web Designing
    expert and found your blog as the best!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi

    good information and there are many and more people like these information.

    - J.
    Web Solutions

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous1:17 PM

    Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
    Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sarah5:22 PM

    That's great! Actually a single step is the base of a big success...Good luck!

    Sarah
    Daily FreebiesAdministrator

    ReplyDelete
  11. Your blog is very nice... i like your blog. Free Web Directory

    ReplyDelete
  12. We Make Buying Cialis Easy. Whether you're a first-time Cialis online buyer or want to Buy Cialis for your first time, we can help with all your buying questions - from how to buy cialis online to clinical Cialis data.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Interesting blog, the author thanks so much for the interesting explanation!
    Keep it up, great success! Bloggy wish a lot of good posts!




    pharmacy online pharmacy online
    pharmacy online pharmacie en ligne

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anonymous9:28 PM

    Your personal information is secure & confidential
    payday loan lenders

    ReplyDelete
  15. Anonymous12:32 PM

    [url=http://www.scribd.com/doc/26409086/Buy-Viagra-Without-Prescription][/url]
    [url=http://www.scribd.com/doc/26409913/Generic-Cialis][/url]
    [url=http://www.pyzam.com/profile/3330487][/url]

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anonymous10:40 PM

    FDA has approved only PROPECIA for treating some types of male pattern hair loss. http://prohairlosspills.com/

    Propecia - generic name Finasteride

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous11:14 PM

    Generische Medikamente machen die gleiche Wirkung im Kцrper als die Marken-Medikamenten apotheke viagra

    ReplyDelete
  18. Your blog is very interesting and I like to read it!

    ReplyDelete
  19. You have a very good blog that the main thing a lot of interesting and useful!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous10:46 AM

    Viagra Online in Texas Buy Viagra for lowest prices! Cheap Viagra online is guaranteed! ORDER VIAGRA - CLICK HERE! We provide only HIGH QUALITY Viagra. Cialis and Viagra Blog. About Cialis and Viagra.

    We Make Buying Cialis Easy. Whether you're a first-time Cialis online buyer or want to Buy Cialis for your first time, we can help with all your buying questions - from how to buy cialis online to clinical Cialis data.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Amazing news! Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anonymous7:33 AM

    I need to learn how to lose weight and stop using cars for moving around.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The financial bleeding of keeping these two cities alive was costing Flexcar dearly, yet the hope that the regional and local governments would really get behind carsharing was always just around the corner. And Flexcar's feast-or-famine approach and staff turnover, didn't help either.cara meninggikan badan

    ReplyDelete
  24. It's never easy to take something away from loyal customers, but what's also gotten the blogosphere worked up is how poorly Zipcar seemed to handle the transition. tinggi badan

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anonymous2:58 PM

    Shalom! Ernest Ramirez . payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  26. Anonymous3:28 PM

    toronto bad credit loans This website is excellent I enjoyed reading it a lot
    AAA Toronto Payday Loans 1172 Bay St #101, Toronto, ON M5S 2B4 (416) 477-2817

    ReplyDelete
  27. greetings to all.
    I would first like to thank the writers of this blog by sharing information, a few years ago I read a book called costa rica investment in this book deal with questions like this one

    ReplyDelete
  28. Costa Rica is an excellent country to invest in real estate its economy is very stable, being a peaceful country and have their exuberant nature makes it much more attractive costa rica best investment in your life!!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Anonymous11:26 PM

    Generic Viagra contains Sildenafil and it is a prescription drug used to treat erectile dysfunction. Erectile dysfunction is the inability of the penis to become rigid, or stay firm long enough to complete the sexual act.Generic Viagra is used to increase blood flow to certain areas of the body, as a muscle relaxant and as a male impotence or erectile dysfunction treatment. Generic Propecia is a one-a-day, FDA-approved, treatment for male pattern hair loss at the crown or in the middle of the scalp (androgenetic alopecia). Generic Viagra is the world renowned medicine for erectile dysfunction and most men have forgotten they ever had a problem with erections after its use. Take it on empty stomach and it will work in 30 minutes. Erections can be achieved on stimulation.Generic Cialis is consumed orally and has quickly become one of the most prescribed medications. Generic Levitra has been clinically proven to improve erectile function, even in men who had other health factors, like high cholesterol, high blood pressure, or diabetes

    ReplyDelete
  30. Buy Viagra at low price is discount online pharmacy offering Viagra online forless. Our viagra online pharmacy is internet's leading online pharmacy at affordable at affordable discount prices.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Thanks for sharing such informative post!!
    Regards,
    Laura Hill

    ReplyDelete
  32. I like your style, the fact that your site is a little bit different makes it so interesting, I get fed up of seeing same-old-same-old all of the time.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Good afternoon readers, it is a pleasure for me to express my opinion in this short article, I think is great, I think you have much talent as writers, should devote himself to publishing on the net post, I am very grateful to you for sharing this information with us

    ReplyDelete
  34. It's great when you are just surfing the web and find something wonderful like this!

    ReplyDelete
  35. You have done a great job… I think you missed on a point or two but that is completely okay when in comparison to the intricate details you have shared. Excellent work…

    ReplyDelete
  36. Thanks a lot for this awesome information about Flexcar. I would like to read few more articles related to Flexcar......


    Smith Alan

    ReplyDelete
  37. hello, i think that this post is the best that i have read because has useful information.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Awaiting my appetizers and in between thought to search web. However looking at this I am not really hungry any more. Here I go.

    best e cigarette

    ReplyDelete
  39. Appropriately said. It is peak time that we individuals start employing our mind and even stay focus in life.

    smoke free electronic cigarette

    ReplyDelete
  40. Nice post but many assumptions. Flexcar actually had over 200 cars in Southern California collectively and over 10,000 members.

    ReplyDelete
  41. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  42. I love Los Angeles. There really is no place like it in the world. There are more things about LA that I adore than I could possibly put into one readable article, so I will limit myself to a the things that keep me coming back. The three things LA just blows every other city in the USA out of the water with are convenience, culture, and beauty sex chat for freeEscorts In London

    ReplyDelete
  43. Flexcar has decreased pretty much in the last couple of years. I'm not sure if it already has another owner of what's going on but the company is not the same one.

    ReplyDelete
  44. I wish this a great peice of vote and thank you for sharing this info and its a best source of valuable info for my readers , posted them with this info. i wish they all like it also.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Have you ever considered about adding a little bit more than just your articles? Order Biltricide 600mg mean, what you say is important and everything. Nevertheless just imagine if you added some great pictures or video clips to give your posts more, "pop"! Your content is excellent but with images and videos, Buy Aldara Cream blog could undeniably be one of the most beneficial in its field. Awesome blog!

    ReplyDelete
  46. You have done really very good site. Great work, great site! Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  47. I'm so glad I found this post because I've been looking for some information.

    ReplyDelete