Showing posts with label Taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Taxes. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Carsharing and Rental Car Taxes

A (hopefully) low-profile bill is passing through the New Jersey legislature that would exempt carsharing from the $5 per trip rental car tax, according to the Associated Press.

The measure is sponsored by Ruben Ramos Jr., D-Hoboken, and will certainly help that city's Corner Cars program (operated by Connect by Hertz), as well as Zipcar members in the Garden State.

The idea of taxing carsharing like a rental car transaction doesn't go away because:

  • Many people still don't "get" carsharing and continue to see it as some sort of "hourly car rental"
  • Governments are hurting for revenues and this look like an easy and fair (if you don't understand what carsharing is) way to increase revenues

To most of us exempting carsharing from rental car taxes is a no brainer.  In most places, rental car taxes are dedicated to tourism and convention promotion, but carsharing is primarily a mobility option for local residents.  So, on the most fundamental level, why would you tax something you want more of?  Yet, it's an issue that doesn't seem to go away and one that is probably going to have to be resolved on a state by state and possibly even, city by city basis.

New Jersey isn't the first place to struggle with this issue: Flexcar in Washington State also faced the issue a couple of years ago.  The state decided that some longer trips made in carsharing vehicles looked an awful lot like car rental trips and not like than the classic 4-5 hour around town carsharing trip.  Yes, some trips taken by carsharing may be as long as a car rental trip but, to me, if you just had to tax something, I'd base the distinction on whether the trip was they taken by people from out of the area or not (which Washington officials said was too difficult!)

Word to the wise: if your carshare isn't exempt from rental car taxes, why not?  It won't happen overnight but doesn't take that much time or effort.  Start by finding an advocate in the appropriate level of government (that the tax is levied at) to introduce legislation.  You'll have all sorts of supporters and few detractors.  Just be ready for one of the car rental giants to show up at the hearings claiming that car rental is "just like carsharing" (as they have done in Chicago) and should be entitled to the same benefit.  NOT! (until they show that they deliver the same benefits to society).

If you're wonky on the subject, the Tax Foundation posted this informed discussion about rental car taxation.  Thanks to RelayRides for Tweeting the link to this article the other day.

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

Update on Rental Car Taxes

Sara Nassauer has written a very informative article for the Wall Street Journal about the current state of carsharing and rental car taxes.

Currently, carsharing customers are paying the state or local jurisdictions' rental car taxes in Washington state, Pittsburgh, Pa., Chicago, Ill., Boston, Mass., New York, New Jersey and Philadelphia, Pa. These car rental taxes are in addition to sales taxes.

Nassauer reports, "In 2006, Chicago exempted car sharing from the city’s car-rental tax on hourly rentals but not daily rentals. Boston allows Zipcar to charge members a flat annual “convention center tax” of $10, instead of the $10 per rental it charges customers of traditional rental-car companies..."

Even with Enterprise in the carsharing business, the article suggests that rental car companies may be using carsharing as leverage in their efforts to get the taxes lowered or removed. The article mentions efforts to straighten out the car rental tax mess in Chicago and Washington state and the possibility of imposing the tax on Colorado's two non-profit carshares.

Rental car taxes typically are used to fund convention and visitor services. Carsharing companies argue that since their members are local and not the prime users of these facilities they should be exempt. (In one case I'm familiar with, here in Portland, rentals to local residents are already exempt but rental car companies seem to continue to charge the tax anyway.)

So, word to the wise: if your car rental tax is levied locally, get to work right now and get carsharing defined and exempted from the tax. We shouldn't be taxing the things we want to promote!

Friday, September 07, 2007

Flexcar Forced to Charge Rental Tax in Seattle

NOTE: This has been updated as of November 2007)

In a step backwards for carsharing, the State of Washington is insisting that Flexcar start charging members the 9.7% rental car tax. That brings the total tax to 18.6% on top of the $10 per hour usage!

The Seattle Times reports:

"Mike Gowrylow, spokesman for the Department of Revenue, said regardless of Flexcar's mission, it is a car rental business and should be taxed as one, just as any car-sharing business would be. "We need to be collecting the tax," he said. As for it targeting local residents, Gowrylow said, there's no way to distinguish who rents cars from the state-ordered tax. He added that any company, like Flexcar, can be billed for any taxes they should have been collecting for the past three years.

That could be a big number.

Flexcar isn't alone. To the north Community Car Share of Bellingham has been charging members the rental car tax since they started a year ago. And I've reported on the fiasco on Chicago with Zipcar and Enterprise Rent A Car stirring up the pot sufficiently that I-Go had to start charging their members the tax even though they had specifically been exempt before.

What can be done? Obviously, this is a political problem, so it will have a political solution - get the state, county, or city (whatever jurisdiction levies rental car taxes) to understand the difference between car rental and car sharing by formulating a definition and getting it passed by the appropriate body. It will be important to craft a definition that avoids including hourly car rental offerings, such as those by Enterprise and Hertz, unless they can show that they provide similar social, environmental benefits as carsharing.

I think carsharing adovcates in Washington state shouldn't have too hard a time making their case against the tax - there's both a for-profit and a non-profit carshare so there's no favoritism there; there are thousands of passionate members who are also voters; there's King County Metro, the visionary transit agency with a long-standing relationship with carsharing. Together they should be able to find a state legislator, if not the governor, willing to move legislation forward to sort this out.

Easy for me to say. (We took care of this problem in Portland during our second year with a specific exemption from Multnomah County, which levies the tax here.) You can read the full newspaper report here and find other information using Google News search to the right.

UPDATE: Apparently, the state Dept. of Revenue couldn't (or wouldn't) bend on their interpretation of their definition that carsharing was the same as rental cars. As reported in the Seattle Times on Oct. 26 Flexcar will begin charging the tax on November 1, which will increase usage fees about $1 per hour. Flexcar, and Community Car in Bellingham, no doubt already have plans to take their case to the Washington legislature.

Tuesday, April 18, 2006

Why Shouldn't Carsharing Pay Rental Car Taxes?

The short answer is - because they're not the same thing!

As you may be aware there's a debate going on in Chicago about whether carsharing companies should have to pay the same 6% rental car tax that traditional daily car rental companies do.

Here's some background: until recently it appeared that non-profit carsharing (i.e. I-Go Cars) was exempt from a rental car tax which a for-profit carsharing company would have to pay. A couple of years ago, Zipcar, thinking about expanding to Chicago some day, started the ball rolling to get for-profit carsharing exempt from the tax as well. Now they've stirred up a minor hornets' nest in the Windy City and I-Go, the non-profit home town carshare, has ended up having to call every member to warn them that they will have to start charging the tax until the dust settles.

Further complicating things is the fact that Enterprise Rent A Car got in the act saying that if carsharing was exempt from the tax, they should be exempt, too! What's a politician in Illinois to make of all this?

It's worth remembering that the purpose of the rental car tax in most cities, including Chicago, is to fund convention and visitor services. Given the membership requirements of carsharing companies, usage by out of towners is virtually nil.

I think it's important for carshares to keep the distinction clear in peoples' minds that carsharing is more than just "hourly car rental" (a shorthand phrase sometimes used to describe carsharing). It has a different purpose - to provide an alternative to car ownership - not just be a replacement car when your regular car is in the shop or you're visiting another city. Studies in several cities have shown that the percentage of carsharing members that either sold a car or avoided buying one is over 50% for both for-profit and non-profit companies.

My belief is that any company that's providing an alternative to car ownership that carsharing has demonstrated should be exempt from the tax - whether for-profit or non-profit. And if Enterprise can show it has a similar effect on consumer car ownership behavior, then let them be exempt too.

My advice to carshares everywhere - get yourself specifically exempt from rental car tax in your area. It's much easier to do it proactively! A little history: when we started CarSharing Portland in 1998 one of my early efforts was to get language adopted by the county commissioners in Portland to specifically exempt carsharing from the rental car tax. (I haven't checked recently, but at the time I noticed that the actual regulations in Portland exempted longer-term car rentals from the tax, but no one at the car rental agencies seemed to be aware of it.)

Dr. Susan Shaheen, UC Berkeley carsharing researcher wrote a very good letter to one of the Chicago papers explaining why this tax is a bad idea Illinois tax puts car-sharing in slow lane. Take a look at it by clicking the LINK below.