Showing posts with label insurance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label insurance. Show all posts

Saturday, May 03, 2008

Zipcar Finally Gets Insurance Right


My earlier post from February 2007 was highly critical of the deceptive way that Zipcar was talking to members about their insurance coverage. One of the side effects of the Flexcar - Zipcar merger/buy out was that Zipcar inherited Flexcar's insurance and started offering it system wide.

So I'm pleased (and overdue) in reporting that Zipcar is now telling it like it is. Here's what Zipcar now says:

"Beginning November 1, 2007, for Zipcar members 21 years of age or older, our insurance coverage consists of a combined single limit of $300,000 per accident, meaning that all third party bodily injuries, or property damage costs relating to the accident covered in the aggregate up to $300,000."

While this isn't the $1 million coverage that City Carshare offers in San Francisco it's still reasonable coverage.

The picture isn't quite so good for the 18-20 year olds driving Zipcars on various college and university campuses, as Zipcar hints at:

"For drivers under 21, we provide coverage up to state-mandated levels, which vary by the state in which the accident occurs. Zipcars are covered under a vehicle collision policy."

In most states these "state-mandated levels" means the minimal $25,000-$50,000 coverage - the same as rental car companies offer (and the coverage that Zipcar used to offer all members). Flexcar used to require 18-20 year old members to show proof of coverage on a personal auto policy but I've been unable to locate a clear description on the Zipcar web site of a similar requirement.

Something else related to insurance: Zipcar is finally doing something that Conrad Wagner and I suggested to Flexcar years ago - offer members the option of paying a small annual fee for a lower deductible.  It's been offered by Canadian carsharing companies Autoshare, Cooperative Auto Network and CommunAuto for some time.  Members age 21+ have the option to purchase a damage fee waiver for $50 per year to reduce that amount to $250 or have $0 deductible for $75/year. The waivers apply for one year from the date initiated (not necessarily the same period as their annual membership).

The full information on Zipcar's insurance and waivers for 21+ year old members can be found here.

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Zipcar Comes Clean about Insurance


While I'm congratulating Zipcar, I should acknowledge that they have finally updated the explanation on their website about how their insurance works. It's light-years ahead of their previously misleading description, which I commented on earlier.

They've even included a convenient state by state summary of minimum required liability coverage limits which you can see here. However, the website is still silent about whether the coverage includes uninsured motorist coverage or not.

As I've said before, while I don't think that state minimum liability is the coverage most people would want to have when they're driving, as long as they don't mislead prospective customers and members, the insurance coverage Zipcar offers is their decision.

Now that carsharing is growing up, hopefully the carsharing companies will be able to develop some creative insurance options. For example, I've always thought that a nice revenue stream could be developed if members could choose the level of insurance coverage they want - e.g, regular membership is $50/year and you could get $300,000 insurance coverage for $100/year membership.

A link to Zipcar's improved insurance description can be found here.

Thursday, June 07, 2007

U-Haul Gets in the Carsharing Game


They are probably the last company I would have imagined interested in carsharing, so I actually didn't realize what I was looking at the first time I drove by a line of white PT Cruisers on a U Haul Truck Rental location in Portland recently.

But perhaps there's some logic to it. Like the car rental business, truck rentals must be very competitive and I would be surprised if there was much growth potential in their industry at this point, so carsharing is a related business and one that doesn't cannabalize from their existing core business. I think that U-Haul has two important things going for it: name recognition and many neighborhood locations (think of their parking lots as big pod locations of vehicles). On the negative side, the internet is full of messages from people complaining about the U-Haul's poor customer service.

The website, UCarshare.com, says the rates are $10/hour or $65/day including gas and apparently full insurance coverage. There is a $25 application fee and $50/year membership. A charge card must be supplied as part of the application process.

The website lists 15 locations in 9 cities that will initially offer the service, all in cities that currently have carsharing operations. Possibly they want to avoid having to educate people as to what carsharing is and find out how competitive their service will be. The cities are: Austin, Ann Arbor, Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Portland, Seattle, and Washington DC.

Right now the sole vehicle option appears to be the Chrysler PT Cruiser. I've always thought the PT Cruiser would be an excellent choice for a carsharing vehicle - it's versatile, distinctive and it's reasonably priced. (But then I started my company with all Dodge Neons, on which the PT Cruiser is based, so one would be entitled to question my judgement.) For what it's worth, all the vehicles in Portland were purchased from a dealer in U-Haul's home town of Phoenix, Arizona.

U Car Share has definitely been paying attention to the other carshares, with a catchy slogan that's definitely environmentally-oriented: Reduce, Replenish, Sustain that appears on the back of the some of the vehicles - saying that it's all about "reducing our carbon footprint and our reliance on fossil fuels" and that they have partnered with "GoZero" carbon offset program of the The Conservation Fund. The backs of other vehicles proclaim: "Where will you go next? Electronics store, Wholesale store, Furniture store"

As of today U-Haul's carsharing service doesn't appear to be ready to roll - the U Haul web site still isn't set up for hourly rental yet and vehicles don't appear to have any electronics in them. Apparently they know they're not ready, since the website says, "After you receive your [reservation] confirmation, simply stop by your office location and get the keys to your car". And the people at my U-Haul branch weren't familiar with how much the service actually cost, referring me to the website. I was told that in the two weeks since they got the cars "about 5 people had inquired about it" (no doubt several from Flexcar branch here) and no cars had been rented.

U Haul truck rental allows people down to age 18 and there's no reference to minimum age for carsharing on the website. The paperwork shows the the same insurance carrier that is listed for the truck insurance is providing the carsharing vehicle insurance. In addition to the standard MVR check, the member agreement says they will use the CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Evaluation) report, which also includes a look at the applicant's insurance claim history, and results in a few more people being denied.

If only they'd talked to me before they started!

Friday, February 09, 2007

Zipcar Insurance Coverage


It's no secret that insurance for carsharing continues to be a problem for operators. Now Zipcar's "little secret" about its insurance coverage has come out in the open - of the blogosphere, at least. FelixSalmon has done the entire carsharing industry a favor making this public in two long posts to this blog.

The issue is how members are covered by Zipcar's insurance. It would appear that the coverage Zipcar actually provides is little different than what rental car companies offer - state minimum liability-only coverage. My attitude is that Zipcar can offer whatever they want to offer, but they shouldn't disguise what they're doing.

Zipcar's explanation on their website of how their insurance coverage works starts out trying hard to distinguish themselves from rental car coverage:

"Unlike rental car companies, we don't make you pay more for basic insurance coverage. Insurance is just part of your Zipcar membership. Nice, huh?"

But the heart of the matter on the Insurance web page is the following statement:

"We provide coverage for damage to the vehicles, other property, and injured parties to the minimums required by the states in which we operate."

As anyone who's ever owned or rented a car knows, these state minimums are laughably low - not what most Zipcar members have (or would have) on any personal vehicle they owned, I'll bet. Caveat emptor. The full text of the page is posted in first comment below.

What's most surprising to me about this whole thing is that Zipcar's competitors have not made very much of a big deal about the fact that DO provide much better insurance.

So if you enjoy a good mystery story, click on the FelixSalmon link (above) to read the full blog postings, including a response from Zipcar management.

Thursday, August 03, 2006

Carsharing for 18-20 year olds becomes a reality


(Corrected Posting)

The minimum age for carsharing just got lower, sort of.

Last month Philly Carshare quietly announced that 18-20 year olds could join as regular members. This week Flexcar announced they would offer a similar, but not quite the same, opportunity for college students at 5 universities to join.

The coverage of the two programs is different: while both require that the student be included on a parent's personal auto policy, in the Philly program, their insurance is "excess" to the personal policy. This means that in the event of an accident the parents' policy comes into play first, and the carsharing policy only pays claims for any amounts above the limits of the parents' policy. In Flexcar's offering, their insurance continues to be primary and the personal auto policy is excess. Flexcar's offering requires members to pay an additional security deposit, while Philly Carshare does not. It seems likely that Flexcar's security deposit is an internal decision and not a requirement of their insurance carrier.

So far there's no word from Zipcar.

Here's the way Philly Carshare's program works: PhillyCarShare provides $1 million of excess collision and liability insurance to you at no additional cost. Pretty amazing, huh? But if you're aged 18 to 20, we do require you to carry your own very basic insurance at Pennsylvania minimums (Bodily injury (one person): $15k; (all people): $30k; Property damage: $5k). The procedure for joining is to e-mail or fax them a copy of the parent’s insurance card, have a parent sign a form acknowledging the student's participation in carsharing and verifying coverage on their policy. If the student has their own insurance, they simply e-mail or fax a copy of their insurance card.

Flexcar's 18-20 year old insurance program is billed as a "pilot" at 5 universities around the country:
Emory University, Atlanta
University of California, Berkeley
University of California, Los Angeles
University of California, San Diego
University of Maryland
University of Portland
This program gives Flexcar a significant advantage in negotiating with higher ed, since a goal of many schools is to prohibit Freshman, and sometimes subsequent years, from bringing cars to campus. The $250 security deposit is refunded when the member turns 21 or they leave the program. Flexcar's description of the program is here .

Philly goes one step further, promoting a $0 deductible damage option by encouraging members to pay their PhillyCarShare bills using a qualifying Visa card. These include: Visa Classic, Visa Secured, Visa Gold, Visa Platinum, Visa Signature. They warn about Visa debit cards and indicate that members with Mastercard and American Express cards should check with the issuing bank about coverage. In the past Visa and other "gold card" issuers have imposed limits on coverage for rental longer 2 weeks, as well as other limitations, so it will be interesting to see how they control their expenses with carsharing.

It's worth remembering that Zipcar was the first to provide coverage for 18-20 year olds in their unique program that started in the fall of 2004 with Wellesley College, near Boston. In that program the college picked up the coverage for younger drivers as part of its general liability insurance. The coverage was similar to that extended to students driving a university vehicle, such as for an "outdoor club" event.

With these offering, hopefully when insurance renewal comes around next time for all carshares, there will be a lot more coverage options on the table. National Indemnity, can you hear me?