Friday, November 27, 2009

Next Big Thing, part 1: Car2Go in Austin

In what seems like an unlikely place to launch a new mobility service, Daimler AG chose Austin, Texas, as the site for initial foray into North America. I say unlikely because, as urban and green and uncharacteristic of Texas as Austin is, it's got a long way to go before it matches the land use patterns and car-lite development of other "classic" carsharing cities.

And launch they have: 200 vehicles all over the downtown area. (Full disclosure: through my association with Team Red mobility network, I consulted with car2Go during the early days of the Austin project.)

When I asked them about this, Daimler officials half jokingly replied that if they can make it work in Austin it can work anywhere. And they're probably right, too. Because Car2Go is really quite different from other carsharing services. It has taken me a long time to wrap my head around the mobility and transportation implications of the Car2Go service model.

What is the "next big thing" about Car2Go? Basically, this:

- On demand usage - no need to have to make a reservation and specify a return time
- One way trips - pay by the minute
- Floating parking - greater flexibility in cities with parking congestion

Car2Go Austin rates are 35¢ per minute - perfect for one-way trips - and are discounted for longer uses: $12.99 an hour or $65.99 for a full day. That means if your trip is longer than 37 minutes the hourly rate kicks in or trips longer 5 hour the daily rate kicks in. Vehicles are geo-fenced and cannot be taken more than 200 miles from Austin.

I'm assuming that the majority of trips are likely to be spontaneous but the system does allows members to reserve vehicles up to 24 hours or as little as 15 minutes in advance. They do not allow more than 5 reservations in a 24 hour period and they must be separated by at least 30 minutes. A vehicle cannot be rented for more than 30 days. Reservations can be cancelled as little as 15 minutes before the trip start without charge.

As with other carsharing companies, car2go maintenance staff will clean vehicles but unlike traditional carsharing, the staff will also refuel vehicles as needed. Fuel cards are provided for a member on a long trip to refuel the vehicle and, as with other carshares, member are not supposed to return a vehicle with less 1/4 tank. If they do refuel, 10 minutes deducted from the trip time.

As with Hertz Conect, car2go only provides state minimum liability insurance assuming that most users will have their own personal auto insurance coverage. This is something I have ranted against in past postings as it undercuts the attractiveness of using the service as an alternative to car ownership. Having said that, I think it illustrates the different concept that Daimler has in mind for car2go.

Take a moment (actually 4 minutes) and watch the way car2go describes itself:




Personal Public Transport

Where car2go seems to be headed is not as another more fully featured, more convenient carsharing service, which it certainly is (albeit with a highly specialized class of vehicles), but something different. This phrase - "personal public transport" (from the video above) perfectly describes what they have in mind. Car2go is not focusing on serving the car-less households of America - it's providing "public" transportation for everyone - a much bigger market. Regarding the Autolib project in Paris, many people have observed that the one-way trip option does compete with public transportation (more precisely "collective transport") but I'm now not sure whether it's a bad thing or not.

First Velib, then the Bixi people in Montreal have demonstrated a notion that an individual transportation mode (a bicycle) can be "public" as well - not only because it's government sponsored or sanctioned, but also because the mode helps meet other social and environmental goals. So why shouldn't it be worthy of public support? The fact that we're talking about cars rather than bicycles with car2go or Autolib changes the equation but perhaps not as much as I had earlier assumed. One argument might be context: if a location has limited transportation alternatives, would a fleet of Smart cars making a whole bunch of 1 way trips be any worse than 1/4 full buses or a bunch of taxicabs, as in New York City?

Austin and Ulm

The City of Austin is to be commended for staying with the project, even during time of budget problems, the city stayed with the project. The use of a car2go vehicle includes free parking at meters and city-owned garages. Car2go is paying a usage fee to the City of Austin in the form of free driving minutes for employees driving on City business.

Austin has partnered with Car2Go with an arrangement that allows free use by city workers on business in return for designating 40 reserved parking spaces around downtown and 85 spaces in municipal garages and parking lots. The rest will be (in the words of the Austin Statesman) "free-range Smart cars", as long as the trip ends within a "geo-fence" roughly bounded by 51st Street, MoPac Boulevard (Loop 1), Oltorf Street and Interstate 35. Of course, traditional carsharing round trips may extend outside that area.

There are some interesting differences and similarities between Ulm and Austin:

Ulm - 120,000 people living in 119 sq. km. = 1,023 people per square kilometer
Austin - 750,000 people living in 767 sq. km = 1,252 square kilometer

But Ulm has excellent transportation network and supportive land use patterns and Austin, with its good, by American standards (but arguably under-appreciated) public transport system including a new light rail line), is still an auto-oriented city, except for a few areas downtown and around the University of Texas.

So now that Ulm has been operational for a year, what is Daimler learning? After a little over a year 15,000 of the city's 80,000 driving age residents are members of Car2Go, according to Nicholas Cole, Car2Go North America, president. The Daimler press release has other interesting numbers from Ulm:

The 200 smarts of the first pilot are rented 500 to 1,000 times per day and they are used by 15,000 customers which equals more than 15 percent of the citizens who possess a driver’s license in Ulm. 90 percent of the participants take advantage of the unique offer to use car2go spontaneously without booking in advance and for one-way trips.

The goal of the Austin pilot project is to gather experience we can use to ensure the public launch of car2go in North America in 2010 is successful," says Nicholas Cole, CEO of car2go North America LLC. "In the second phase we will increase the number of cars in Austin and open the service to the public. We are also talking to a large number of cities in North America and Europe about additional rollouts of car2go."

Hmmmmmm...

PS: Although there isn't an iPhone app for the Car2Go in Austin, yet (it's on the way, I'm told), die hard US iPhone enthusiasts will want to keep close tabs on the Ulm Car2Go fleet by downloading the app Go2Car (free). It shows the current location of the vehicle, whether it's in use or not and the fuel level.

Sunday, October 25, 2009

Is Our Love Affair With Cars Cooling?

A recent article entitled "Rebel without a car" that appeared in the Los Angeles Times Business section on Oct. 9, 2009 indicates that a shift in attitudes is beginning to happen in the USA, at least among the younger generation.

The article, reported by Martin Zimmerman, cites a J.D. Power and Associates market research report that:

"Online discussions by teens indicate shifts in perceptions regarding the necessity of and desire to own cars." Part of the reason, the article says is that during the current recession "the cost of owning a car probably makes less sense than it did when gas was 30¢ per gallon..." The report suggests that, "with the advent of social media and other forms of electronic communities, teens perceive less of a need to physically congregate and less of a need for a mode of transportation."

The analysis focused on teens, ages 12-18, and "early careerists", ages 22-29. The change in was identified from monitoring hundreds of thousands of auto-related websites, blogs, and social networks such as Twitter and Facebook.

The comments about the article on the LA Times blogsite were also interesting.

Sunday, October 11, 2009

Multi-Mobility in the Los Angeles Basin - Some thoughts about Carsharing and Bicycles


Carsharing was one topics up for consideration at the second Multi-Mobility Forum sponsored by the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority on October 8. The driving force is the SB 375 passed by the California legislature last year mandating substantial cuts in greenhouse gases from transportation by 2020. Attending were representatives from many of the cities in the LA region.

Some people attending remembered the "glory days" of carsharing in Los Angeles region when Flexcar had more than 250 vehicles that were finally starting to generate revenues. They wondered what it would take to attract a major carsharing operator like Zipcar or Hertz Connect back again.

Technically, carsharing never completely left the area. Even before the merger with Zipcar, Flexcar had scaled-back the LA fleet (as they did in other markets, as well) and Zipcar continues to provide about 20 carsharing vehicles at the UCLA and USC campuses and immediately adjacent areas.

In my short presentation I reminded everyone that carsharing isn't a transportation demand management strategy by itself (like transit, ridesharing or bicycling), but it's the "glue" that can increase participation in these programs since it provides an alternative to car ownership (or second car ownership). And, as we all know (from personal experience):

Car ownership = Car over-use

Several of the presentations were about bicycle programs, including an interesting program to encourage people to buy folding bicycles for use on transit (see photo at the top of this post). I was personally fascinated by the folding bicycle demonstrated by Big Fish at the forum and also pleased to see the Bike Station was developing a modular approach to provide services through its new incarnation as Mobis.

I think public bicycles have some important lessons for carsharing. Most importantly, the lesson from the Paris Velib system, is to Think Big. Only by thinking big (and doing big) can you attract the kind of public attention that can make a difference. In addition, in my presentation I offered some suggestions for working with carsharing companies. I've posted several of the slides from presentation at the end of this post.

Unfortunately, unable to attend this session was Dan Sturges of Intrago Mobility, who coined the phrase multi-mobility and has one of the clearest visions of what the future of personal transportation could look like. His vision includes a combination of small electric and pedal vehicle for short trips ("near car") and strategically-located carsharing vehicles in clusters near major hubs for longer trips ("far cars"). His company is putting together the system that will make all this possible.


Several cities in the LA area are ripe for large-scale "classic" neighborhood carsharing (again): Long Beach and Santa Monica, in particular and I wish them well. Many thanks to Fred Silver of Calstart and Robin Blair of LA Metro for hosting the event.

Friday, October 09, 2009

CommunAuto - North America's Oldest Auto Partage is 15 Years Old

I was reminded recently how easy it is to lose sight that a lot of what happens in North America happens in Canada. Oh, ya, those guys up there.

Communauto has been growing for 15 years - 5 years longer than any of us Gringos "south of the border". It was founded by Benoît Robert and his collaborators in 1994. Now Communauto serves over 20 000 members, has a fleet over 1000 self-serve vehicles, divided throughout 310 parking stations in the greater regions of Quebec City, Montreal, Sherbrooke and Gatineau.

CommunAuto has always done things its own way: started as a school project in 1994, it was a nonprofit with 6 vehicles - 4 Pontiac Fireflies and 2 Ford Festivas. In 1997 Benoit took the company private merging operations in Quebec City and Montreal. (Here's a link to an English translation of his the original market research and a short history of the company in French.) It has unique rate plans not copied from anyone - charging the highest monthly fees and lowest per hour rates of any carshare, anywhere - as low as $1.60 per hour on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday.

And CommunAuto has traditional kept its vehicles in service much longer than other carshares, up to 5 years at one point, giving them much better cost structure.

Something else CommunAuto has done that very few others have is a detailed analysis of greenhouse gas reduction from their operations. Completed in February 2007, the consulting firm of Tecsult estimates that as a result of carsharing each CommunAuto member has reduced their CO2 production by 1.2 tons per year. Tecsult estimates that if the market potential of carsharing was attained, this service alone would lead to a reduction of CO2 emissions equivalent to 5.6 times the reduction targeted for alternative modes of transportation by the 2006-2012 Action Plan – Quebec, all without any costs for the taxpayer. These numbers reflect the fact that almost 90% of CommunAuto member households are car free, much higher that 30-40% typical in the US.

To jump start the 15th anniversary, Communauto organized a photo event on September 5th to make the short film (above) demonstrating the advantages of car sharing in our cities. In October close to 150 people attended a celebration hosted at Montreal’s City Hall with partners, elected representatives and long-lasting users of Communauto’s services revisited the company’s most memorable moments.

Beyond being a role model for many car sharing organizations in North America, Communauto participated in developing a code of ethics subscribed to by many carsharing organizations. On the operation front they have developed partnerships with public transit and taxi companies and, put a lot of effort into integrating Smart electric vehicles in its car fleet, including a recent partnership with Veolia and an earlier project Branché around 2000). Below is a chart of their growth up to 10,000 members.

Bon anniversaire, CommunAuto!

Saturday, August 01, 2009

Hertz Connect Rolling Out New Cities



The new carshare on the street, Connect By Hertz, is showing it means business. After the initial launch in Manhattan, London and Paris, Connect spent some time getting their feet on the ground. But they were busy in the spring and by this summer Connect had expanded their New York fleet to over 400 hundred vehicles - competing in Zipcar's sweetest neighborhoods all over Manhattan. The growth was facilitated by their partnership with Icon Parking, Connect now has locations from the tip of Manhattan up to East and West 90th Streets. In comparison Zip has over 2000 vehicles in several boroughs and adjacent New Jersey communities).

A recent check of the Hertz Connect web site now lists Boston, Chicago, Washington DC and San Francisco, each with one location with several vehicles. In Chicago, for example, the downtown Loop location has 4 vehicles - 2 Priuses, a Ford Escape SUV and a Camry. (The Washington DC location is at Marriot hotel corporate headquarters and could be laying the groundwork for a very interesting partnership.) Oddly Denver isn't one of the cities listed, although the Spire condo project there indicates they'll be offering residents Connect services. That would make Denver the city with the most carsharing services right now - E-Go (Boulder Carshare), Occasional Car (a recent start up with 2 vehicles) and Hertz Connect.

And Connect has added a couple of college/university campuses to its list - having taken them away from Zipcar. These are naturals for Connect since Hertz likely has a branch in the town so adding carsharing is a piece of cake.

But exactly how they're achieving this growth is a bit of a mystery - since they don't seem to be using any of the traditional marketing approaches - transit advertising, media trade outs, etc. They have done some interesting awareness campaigns using Go Gorilla Media including sidewalk logo projections, sidewalk stenciling (is that legal?) and fake "lost dog" signs (the tear offs give the Hertz Connect web site).
Hertz Connect is going after a somewhat different customer demographic - offering more vehicles on the upscale end. In addition to a Mini or a Prius at just about every location, and the usual assortment of Mazda 3s and Toyota Yaris, there are many Camrys and some locations have Volvo C70s and even a Mercedes GLK 350!

Hertz Connect is being helped in NYC by Zipcar's on-going problems with customer service. The Zipcar call center can be infuriating (I know from experience) and fleet maintenance in NYC (and other cities) apparently leaves a LOT to be desired - read a bunch of uphappy Zipcar members complaining (and very few members complimenting) on Yelp.

The London and Paris operations of Connect remain mysteries with only minor expansions of the fleet. But perhaps that's not surprising because Zipcar has been having trouble figuring out the UK market and they've been in London and LOT longer than Hertz Connect. And speaking of mysteries, Mint in New York, is another mystery - very little action since their launch.

And while I'm on the subject of car rental companies operating carsharing, it's worth nothing that U-Carshare by U-Haul has been quietly adding additional cities and a couple of schools, as well. That said, the U-Carshare marketing strategy is also a mystery - almost invisible in my home town of Portland, Oregon (although they finally had a presence at the recent Sunday Parkways event I wrote about earlier).

It's shaping up to be an interesting year in carsharing.

Friday, June 26, 2009

Getting from A to B and transforming transportation along the way


Eric Britton, Robin Chase and others have written eloquently about the urgency for making massive changes in our transportation system. What will offset a big chunk of that car use is pretty clear: a lot more walking and cycling, increased use of public transportation, ridesharing, plus a dash of carsharing!

My guess is this will probably involve some high tech solutions - cell phones and social networking services, electric bikes, etc. - but mostly it's going to be a lot more old fashioned shoe leather and bike tires on the pavement. But right now we have a lot of wonderful solutions and a big gap between what we're doing and where we want to be.

But what combination of factors will motivate a large number of people to change their these transportation habits is a mystery. Carsharing is indeed a "missing link", but it's only one of a number of "missing links" in the chain.


Recently, the City of Portland is sponsored the latest in a series of Sunday Parkways bike rides, attracting thousands of people, families, and kids for a ride through several neighborhoods. Cross streets are controlled and it's a veritable party attracting thousands of people over a 5+ mile circular route. The other part of event is scheduling community groups, food vendors and musicians of all kinds to set up in the parks along the route. It is truly inspiring to see so many people on bikes and it seems can't help create awareness and experience of cycling in a broader section of the population than the "hard core bike commuters". It's a small, but I think important step in the cultural shift in our thinking and transportation habits. You can see a nice Streetfilms video of the first event last year here.

The start of such a shift was reflected in an interesting essay by a Canadian newspaper columnist who characterized the change in the change in their attitude about cars from "object of desire" to "necessary evil". I think this captures one of the cultural shifts perfectly - for so many people cars are now becoming a necessary evil.

Another cultural shift I've been thinking about could be a basic change in the type of cars we own - instead of the maximum car we can afford, we would spend our money on the minimal car we need for 90% of the trips we take. This minimal car wouldn't have to be a "econobox". Daimler has shown there's a market for a $15,000 city car and Europe has got a wide variety of upscale microcars! For now, car ownership in the US is probably too cheap and awareness of the impacts of ownership too limited to see this happening very much.

What's needed now is some good minds to think about the intermediate steps to facilitate this cultural shift and conditions to promote them. With the passage of climate change legislation in the US and a new commitment to addressing environmental problems, the next decade is going to be interesting.

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Carsharing in India

My postings has always been sporadic but none more so than recently. My wife and I were on a 3 week trip to India - our first ever - and it was a stark reminder that most of the rest of world operates under conditions a lot more basic than our gold plated lifestyle. I was also struck by the progressive policies (a ban on plastic bags in Himachal Pradesh for example) and active discussion about climate change in the newspapers.

The transportation system in India was already at capacity - trains were long and very crowded; buses were packed for 12 hours a day; roads were narrow, bumpy and travel was slow. And we could see that even relative prosperity was resulting in rapid expansion in the number private cars - not only the local brands - Maruti Suzuki and Tata but also the traditional "Asian" brands like Honda, Toyota and even new brands like Hyundai, Honda, Toyota and Chevy (!) were in evidence.

For better and worse, the Tata Nano, the $2000 car, has captured the imagination of world. But there were lots of other awfully-darn-small cars already in India, as well as the infamous autorickshaws everywhere. The good news about these autorickshaws in Delhi, at least, is that the city has mandated that all of them, and all buses, be converted to compressed natural gas (CNG).

Remarkably in the few weeks we were there I came across this op ed piece from the Times of India that mentioned carsharing - Can India Really Afford Cheap Cars? by Martin Wright, the editor of the UK-based Green Futures magazine. In the discussion the author wonders if an battery electric Tata Nano would be possible possible and then goes one step further:

You might not be able to afford an electric Nano — but why own something that you don't use every day? So what about a state-sponsored Tata Zero Carbon Car Club, of the sort springing up across European neighbourhoods, giving people the benefits of using a vehicle when they need it, without the hassle and cost of owning one when they don't? It could help cut congestion, too: all the evidence suggests that car club members drive less than private car owners — because they don't feel they have to justify their hefty investment in their vehicle by using it in preference to the bus or metro.


It's worth remembering that India has some street cred in the alternative transportation sector as well - it's the home to the Reva EV (sold in the UK as the G-Wiz). For now most of the carsharing going on in India will continue to be taxis! But what next?